Are Your Team-Building Exercises Creating a Team?
Team leaders have a perennial dilemma: how can we educate, engage, and develop our group in a substantial way that helps the team become better? Team building is often seen as the fun add-on to a meeting devoted to science, sales figures, and quarterly goals. These can include a ropes course, golf, trip to the desert, horseback riding, softball, cooking school, and the like. Were these experiences useful toward the goal? If the goal is fun, distraction, or an open afternoon, then these experiences create shared memories and are often a welcome opportunity.
But the goal is rarely just to have a fun afternoon. Leaders want teams to trust better, to understand at a deeper level, and certainly to communicate with one another in useful ways beyond one afternoon.
Building a team requires three basic elements, and they are the same perpetual needs that all team leaders have: engagement, education, and development…all with a twist.
Engagement…with a twist
Sometimes it’s simple—like a handshake—and other times it’s complex—like securing buy-in for a high-dollar project—but engagement always involves obtaining a “yes” from the other person. This agreement begins a cooperative relationship that seeks to align goals, minimize a judgmental response, and keep the momentum going (even during the naturally tough times that are bound to come).
The commitment of marriage, for example, is symbolized by an engagement ring. In business, commitment is demonstrated with a signed letter or contract. In both instances, engagement is an agreement that both parties will move forward and seek more specific agreements. When people are engaged (in both the marital and business context), there is an interior feeling of security that assures each person that they will work together.
This agreement cannot be secured in one event. Just as hospitals have a heart monitor on every patient, team leaders must constantly monitor the signs of stress, unrest, and frustration. This involves listening to what members of the team say, what they don’t say, and maybe, what they can’t say.
Here is the twist: listening closely to both the words and the feelings of your team members allows you, as the leader, and those who work for you, to feel your engagement. Paraphrasing and empathy are the perennial, highly reliable skills that will help you steer clear of becoming judgmental. When you are in tune with your team members’ unique “heartbeats” of engagement, you will know when somebody becomes an outlier. Only then can you use your other skills to bring them back aboard.
Education…with a twist
Too many meetings are based on lectures. This repetitive structure might have worked for multiplication tables in primary school, but no longer. When teaching adults, presenters actually waste valuable educative time thinking that dumping data, spreadsheets, bullet points, and manuals onto people will somehow enlighten them.
The word “education” comes from the Latin word “educare,” which means “to lead out” or “draw forth from.” Socrates knew this when he asked questions in order to “draw forth from” his students. While this might make sense on paper, it is a more significant shift in how we can really envision meetings. We still, by and large, run our meetings with a speaker or presenter who often says, “Is it okay if I take questions later?” These people will then read their Power Point presentations aloud, droning on and on, while the audience pre-reads each slide and then waits for the presenter to finish.
Instead of a 60-90 minute lecture, what if…
- The presenter didn’t see this as “my time,” but saw “our time” as an opportunity for the team to talk with one another about the essence of the issues?
- The team divided into groups of three, brainstormed three or four concerns for the future, and then had the expert facilitator give a 10-12 minute reflection on each of the concerns?
- The presenter simply had a Q&A session?
- The expert asked the audience questions, guiding the team toward answering the question, “What do we need to do to prepare for the future we want to make?”
Here is the twist: when we ignore that education is really about drawing forth from our collective experience, we waste incredible resources already present in our teams. Witnessing this collective knowledge is a strong formative element for a team. This is often what scientists experience working on a project during a “think-tank” session or what a Broadway cast feels on opening night.
Development…with a twist
This is the most important, yet most often ignored, element when building a team. In an effort to move forward quickly, many leaders start sharing the “takeaways” from the experience before the team has caught its breath. When team leaders say, “I hope that you realized this horseback riding taught us to better listen to one another just as we did with our horses,” they risk the team saying, “What? I thought we just learned there’s some beautiful scenery here!” Instead, team leaders should consider asking the following:
- What did you notice when you tried to steer your horse too hard?
- What did you learn about your colleagues’ lives during the ride?
- For those who have never been horseback riding, what skills did you learn?
- Aren’t those skills some of the same that we need in our office?
Here is the twist: just as we rely on crockpots to slowly heat and mold a meal’s flavors together, we must allow the individuals to apply the lessons for themselves.
Team Building…with a twist
It is okay to take the team golfing, horseback riding, or out for drinks, but don’t think that activity alone will build the team any more than a reception with fine wine and tasty cheese will foster interesting conversation at dinner.
Reconsider how you educate, and how you think about education, because everyone will learn more when the collective team experience is drawn forth. Finally, understand that the act of looking back on what the team learned and experienced together is a vital part of becoming a team…and building one.
Team-building activities don’t typically involve teaching the skills of extraordinary customer service, improv acting, fine dining, or food preparation. Yet one executive used all four to teach his team of pharmaceutical scientists how to reflect on personalities, roles, and goals. The field trips below also resulted in a well-formed team, seriously fun engagement, and a memorable experience beyond any ordinary team meeting:
- A scavenger hunt focused on branding that included visits to Chicago’s Four Seasons hotel, Bloomingdales department store, and the Disney store.
- At Second City, the famous improv school and theater, actors taught techniques to ensure that the team learned the value of saying “yes” on stage.
- Advanced lessons in mealtime etiquette at fancy restaurants prepared the team to impress clients anywhere in the world.
- A master chef showed the team how a first-class kitchen operated smoothly in the midst of chaos.
Each activity was designed to build the team, increase interpersonal skills, and create a useful memory. Not one of these activities was done for its own sake, just for “fun,” or to simply fill the time. Unlike so many “team-building” events that can be downloaded from the Internet, each actually built the team even after the team-building event finished.
About the Author: Kevin E. O’Connor, CSP (firstname.lastname@example.org), is a facilitator, medical educator, and author. His latest book, Fearless Facilitation: The Ultimate Field Guide for Engaging (and Involving!) Your Audience, is available in bookstores and online at www.kevinoc.com.